The Art of the Follow-Up: Staying on Coaches' Radars Without Being Annoying
The difference between persistent and annoying is one email. Here's how to nail it.
There's a fine line between staying on a coach's radar and becoming that athlete they avoid opening emails from. I've seen talented recruits damage their chances by following up too aggressively, and I've watched equally talented athletes disappear from coaches' minds because they never followed up at all. The follow-up is an art form. Done right, it demonstrates genuine interest, professionalism, and maturity. Done wrong, it makes you look desperate or oblivious.
Understanding the coach’s world
College coaches are overwhelmed. They receive hundreds of emails from recruits, parents, and recruiting services. They're evaluating talent, managing current rosters, traveling to events, and handling administrative responsibilities. Your email is one of many they need to process. When coaches don't respond immediately, it's usually not personal. They might be genuinely interested but swamped with more urgent matters, or they're tracking your development but not ready to extend an offer yet. Understanding this context prevents you from taking silence personally or overreacting with excessive follow-ups.
the timing formula
Here's the golden rule: wait 2-3 weeks between contacts unless you have something genuinely new to share. This gives coaches time to process your previous email, evaluate your materials, and potentially respond. If you're following up after a showcase or camp, you can shorten this to 3-5 days with a quick thank-you email. But after that initial follow-up, return to the 2-3 week cycle. Emailing every few days makes you look anxious and inexperienced. The exception: if a coach asks you to follow up at a specific time, honor that timeline exactly.
what to include
Every follow-up email should include something new. Never send the same message twice. Worthy follow-up content includes: updated athletic performance with new stats or achievements, academic improvements like higher GPA or better test scores, schedule of upcoming games where coaches might evaluate you, new highlight film or recent standout footage, notification of attendance at specific camps, or renewed interest after visiting campus. Notice what's not on that list: "just checking in," "following up on my last email," or "wondering if you received my information." Those emails provide zero value and come across as filler. If you don't have something new to share, wait until you do.
structure that works
Keep follow-up emails even shorter than your initial contact, aim for 100 words or less. Subject line: Reference your previous contact and the new information. Opening: Brief reminder of who you are and when you last contacted them, one sentence maximum. Update: The new information you're sharing. Be specific and quantifiable. "I averaged 22 points per game this season" beats "I had a great season." Next step: Your upcoming schedule or what you're working on next. This gives coaches a timeline for future evaluation opportunities. Closing: Professional sign-off with contact information and relevant links.
red flags relationships
Avoid these behaviors: complaining about not receiving a response, mentioning other schools' interest in manipulative ways, asking for updates on their interest level, sending multiple emails before getting a response, being overly casual or using slang, lengthy emails that require significant time investment, or generic emails that could be sent to any coach. The best follow-ups don't feel like follow-ups, they feel like natural relationship building. When you attend a school's game, mention something specific about what you observed. When they win a championship, send congratulations. These touchpoints demonstrate authentic interest. Sometimes the answer is no, even if coaches haven't said it explicitly. If you've followed up three times over 8-10 weeks with substantial updates and received no response, it's probably time to focus your energy elsewhere.
Want expert coaching on communicating with college coaches?
Book a free consultation with Next Play Athletics Consulting at https://www.nextplayathleticsconsulting.com/ for personalized communication strategies today.
